Econstudentlog

Absolute Risk of Suicide After First Hospital Contact in Mental Disorder

This new article is rather awesome, if for no other reason then because it involves so many people and follow them over such a long time-frame:

Objective  To estimate, in a national cohort, the absolute risk of suicide within 36 years after the first psychiatric contact.

Design  Prospective study of incident cases followed up for as long as 36 years. Median follow-up was 18 years.

Setting  Individual data drawn from Danish longitudinal registers.

Participants  A total of 176 347 persons born from January 1, 1955, through December 31, 1991, were followed up from their first contact with secondary mental health services after 15 years of age until death, emigration, disappearance, or the end of 2006. For each participant, 5 matched control individuals were included.”

176.347 people followed for roughly two decades on average. That’s a lot of data. What did they find? Some of the main results:

Results  Among men, the absolute risk of suicide (95% confidence interval [CI]) was highest for bipolar disorder, (7.77%; 6.01%-10.05%), followed by unipolar affective disorder (6.67%; 5.72%-7.78%) and schizophrenia (6.55%; 5.85%-7.34%). Among women, the highest risk was found among women with schizophrenia (4.91%; 95% CI, 4.03%-5.98%), followed by bipolar disorder (4.78%; 3.48%-6.56%). In the nonpsychiatric population, the risk was 0.72% (95% CI, 0.61%-0.86%) for men and 0.26% (0.20%-0.35%) for women. Comorbid substance abuse and comorbid unipolar affective disorder significantly increased the risk. The co-occurrence of deliberate self-harm increased the risk approximately 2-fold. Men with bipolar disorder and deliberate self-harm had the highest risk (17.08%; 95% CI, 11.19%-26.07%).”

As mentioned they of course they didn’t just limit themselves to following ‘the sick people’ – they also needed people to compare them with… So:

“To estimate the cumulative incidence of suicide among people with no history of mental illness, we adopted a slightly alternative strategy. For each person with a history of any mental illness (as defined in the“Assessment of Suicide and Mental Illness” subsection), we randomly selected 5 people of the same sex and same birth date who had no history of mental illness (time matched). Using the described strategy, we followed up this healthy population (881 735 persons) to provide absolute suicide risks. Because this healthy population was selected at random among all 2.46 million people included in the study population, the estimates obtained represent the absolute risk of suicide among all 2.46 million people without a mental disorder.”

Again, that’s a lot of data – representativeness really is unlikely to be an issue here (at least when dealing with the situation in Denmark). As they put it in the paper: “This is the first analysis of the absolute risk of suicide in a total national cohort of individuals followed up from the first psychiatric contact, and it represents, to our knowledge, the hitherto largest sample with the longest and most complete follow-up.”

Results in a bit more detail:


(click to view full size). I’ve previously seen it argued in papers on anorexia that it’s the phychiatric disorder with the highest mortality rate, so I was a bit surprised by the relatively low numbers here. On the other hand that may be related to the fact that they tend to starve themselves to death rather than take their own lives in the traditional sense, which means that a lot of those excess deaths are not considered suicides. Note that a big majority of all suicides committed are committed by people with a mental illness and that the risk increase from a diagnosis is really quite significant; given the estimates, females with a mental illness are more than 8 times as likely to kill themselves than females without a mental illness, and males are 6 times more likely. Schizophrenic females are almost 20 times as likely to commit suicide than are females without a mental illness. Add substance abuse as well and these females are more than 30 times as likely to commit suicide (the absolute risk is around 7% in that case). The risk is substantially increased for almost all groups when you add substance abuse.

Do also note that not all people in the ‘mental illness’ group are actually people with a mental illness; personality disorders are not usually considered mental illnesses by health professionals, but the study includes in the group of people with mental illnesses people with: “any mental illness (any ICD-8 or ICD-10 code) if they had been admitted to a psychiatric hospital or had been in outpatient care with one of these diagnoses.” (The “any ICD-8 or ICD-10 code” means that people with personality disorders are included in the group as well). This is probably ‘fair enough’ given that at least some of these groups clearly have elevated suicide levels, but it’s worth having in mind that it should change the interpretation slightly. How about people who’ve attempted suicide?

The deliberate self-harm/attempted suicide group is obviously a high-risk group. The follow-up period is shorter than for the other estimates (30 years, rather than 36) so these estimates are perhaps best thought of as lower bounds. There’s some uncertainty regarding the estimates because the sample sizes aren’t that big (which is a good thing I think…), but roughly 1 in 6 Danish males with bipolar affective disorder killed themselves during the period. The absolute risks here are substantial; for the ‘any mental illness’ group, one in 12 committed suicide during the period. Although the female numbers are substantially lower for the group as a whole, for some illnesses the absolute risk is comparable to that of the males (and the excess risk much, much higher). More than one in ten females with schizophrenia and a suicide attempt in the past committed suicide during the follow-up period.

I should perhaps mention here that there may be some significant tail risk unaccounted for in the data, despite the long follow-up period which might lead you to think these are good estimates of the ‘lifetime probability of suicide’. The suicide-rate of Danish males above the age of 85 is the highest of all age groups, and it’s five times as high as the suicide risk of males at the age of 25-29 (Danish link). This is not just a Danish thing – similar dynamics have been observed elsewhere. Age matters a lot here, but people tend to care less when old people kill themselves than when young people do.

November 19, 2012 - Posted by | data, health, papers, Psychology

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: